Harvest Prep Senior Captains, The coach says, are "A Special Group"

 

Faith, Leadership, and Legacy: The Senior Captains Who Changed HPS Softball

Documentary

For four seasons, Maya Donaldson, Tofunmi Aluko, and Malaysha Dillinger represented more than softball at Harvest Preparatory School.

They represented faith, leadership, accountability, and consistency.

After spending four years in the HPS softball program — including two years as captains — the trio helped establish what many around the program describe as a spiritual culture that became one of the defining traits of Warriors softball. Their influence stretched beyond wins and losses and into dugouts, classrooms, workplaces, churches, and even opposing fields.

All three were longtime contributors to the program, with Maya Donaldson, Tofunmi Aluko, and Malaysha Dillinger as 4 year starters for Harvest Prep softball.  They were part of what Coach Temple called "The FAB 5." Their freshman year, all 5 started varsity. One quit playing her sophomore year, and Jayana Moore graduated a year early.  The three stuck it out as 4-year starters. Two captains, Jayana and Maya, were the first and second from Harvest Prep to ever be 1st team All Midstate League-Cardinal. Tofunmi and Malaysha earned Honorable Mention.  

Leading Through Faith

What separated this senior class was the way they openly embraced the team’s Christian identity.

The captains regularly organized and led prayers before games — including games against public schools — even when there was occasional resistance or criticism from opposing parents who questioned public expressions of faith during athletic events. Yet the captains remained respectful, composed, and unwavering in their commitment to represent Christ through softball.

Malaysha Dillinger often reminded younger players that “HPS Warriors are a Christian team,” emphasizing communication, encouragement, and accountability on the field. Teammates say she consistently reinforced the importance of representing the school with character and purpose.

Tofunmi Aluko became known for protecting the established culture. Whether discouraging anti-Christian behavior or addressing inappropriate secular music around the team, she was quick to defend the standards the captains believed the program should uphold.

The impact extended beyond the field. Malaysha has preached several times at her church, demonstrating the same confidence and leadership away from athletics that teammates witnessed during games.

Leadership in the Classroom

All three captains were also students in their coach’s calculus classes, where they earned reputations as dependable leaders and positive influences in the classroom.

Teachers and classmates viewed them as respectful, hardworking students who balanced athletics, academics, faith, and work responsibilities while maintaining high standards of character.

Outside of school:

• Two of the captains worked  together at Subway

• One worked at Wendy's

• All three were in school plays and the Black History Production. 

Their willingness to work jobs while managing school and athletics became another example that younger athletes noticed and respected.

The Coach Stayed One More Year

The connection between the captains and their coach became one of the defining stories of the season.

Originally expected to complete a three-year coaching commitment, the coach ultimately returned for another season largely because of the opportunity to coach these senior captains one final year. Their loyalty, leadership, and investment in the program made the decision difficult to walk away from.

Each captain brought a unique leadership style.

Maya Donaldson often served as the emotional balance for the team and coaching staff. During tense moments, she was known for reminding her coach to stay composed with comments such as:

“Be nice, Coach.”
“That wasn’t nice, Coach.”

She also became famous around the program for her constant defensive reminder:

“PUT your glove in the dirt!”

Tofunmi Aluko consistently showed appreciation for her coaches by arriving early, staying late, and helping whenever needed. Coaches often described her as fiercely loyal and quick to defend the people she respected.

Meanwhile, Malaysha Dillinger became one of the clearest voices of accountability and communication for the Warriors, helping ensure the team’s Christian values remained central throughout the season.

Leaving a Lasting Standard

Statistics can measure batting averages, stolen bases, and wins. But the legacy of these captains may ultimately be measured differently.  It is not easy playing for a team that regularly gets run-ruled and ostracized or ignored by school officials and students alike, but these captains kept smiling and leading, praying for and with each other, and opponents. 

They helped establish a culture where prayer became normal, leadership became expected, and younger athletes learned that character mattered just as much as performance.

Long after their final games, the example set by Maya Donaldson, Tofunmi Aluko, and Malaysha Dillinger will remain part of the identity of HPS softball.